Connect with us


On This Day in 1984, ‘A Nightmare on Elm Street’ AND ‘Silent Night, Deadly Night’ Were Released

On This Day in 1984, ‘A Nightmare on Elm Street’ AND ‘Silent Night, Deadly Night’ Were Released

Both prominently featured the colors red and green!

In his must-read The Slasher Movie Book, author J.R. Kerswell pinpoints the years between 1978 and 1984 as being the “golden age” for slasher cinema. John Carpenter’s Halloween no doubt kick-started the sub-genre proper (even if it was very much inspired by Black Christmas, released four years prior), taken to a gory new level with Friday the 13th in 1980 and then, well, run into the ground over the subsequent years by countless imitators.

But though 1984 may have been the end of the so-called “golden age,” it was a year that gave us two of the most unique and successful slasher films of the entire decade.

I’m of course referring to Wes Craven’s A Nightmare on Elm Street and Charles E. Sellier Jr’s Silent Night, Deadly Night, both released on November 9, 1984.

It was on that day that Elm Street arrived in 165 theaters, ahead of a wider release the following week, while the Christmas-themed slasher made its way into 398 theaters. Granted, it’s not fair to compare given one was released into half as many theaters as the other, but it’s interesting to note that SNDN did out-gross Elm Street in their shared opening weekend.

Silent Night, Deadly Night had an opening weekend gross of $1,432,800, coming in #8 at the box office, topping Elm Street‘s 10th place arrival with $1,271,100.

Of course, A Nightmare on Elm Street went on to enjoy big time box office success, while the controversial Silent Night was pulled from theaters after its second week.

True, 1984 may have overall represented the decline of the slasher sub-genre, but one could say that even the sub-genre’s worst year was capped off with two of its best films. With A Nightmare on Elm Street, Wes Craven introduced the most iconic slasher villain of all time in Freddy Krueger, blending dreams with reality to inject new life into the tired body count formula. While most slashers in the wake of Friday the 13th were little more than Friday the 13th knockoffs, Elm Street was boldly original, changing the game entirely.

And let’s not discredit Silent Night, Deadly Night, which also spawned a long-running franchise and similarly brought freshness to the slasher sub-genre. Rather than simply copying the tried and true slasher formula, the filmmakers instead decided to go in a wholly different direction, presenting the gory slayings in a way that set SNDN apart from the pack.

We agreed that the most interesting and fun way to do it would be to examine the sequence of events that lead, like dominoes falling, to Billy-as-Santa’s ultimate Christmas eve killing spree,” writer Michael Hickey explained to me during a chat back in 2014, “rather than following the usual approach of focusing on the victims.”

Together, A Nightmare on Elm Street and Silent Night, Deadly Night make a damn good case for November 9th being one of the most important dates in the history of the slasher film. One brought mainstream success to the table, while the other brought mainstream press and notoriety to the widely disregarded sub-genre.

Anyone up for a double feature tonight?



  • Aaron King

    Happy birthday to two of the best horror flicks from the year I was born!

  • MrX13

    I never knew that both movies came out at the same time! I enjoyed both these movies!

  • biff

    Although I typically save it for later in the year, I’ll have to watch Silent Night, Deadly Night this evening. It’ll be NAUGHTY!

  • MeeGhoulz

    The remake of one of these is actually great, the other not at all… guess which is which?

    • Necro

      Was ‘Silent Night’ a remake of ‘Silent Night, Deadly Night’? I’m being serious cuz well the ‘Deadly Night’ part was missing from the title and typically remakes have the exact same title. I mean I know there’s a killer Santa running around in that one as well, I thought it was just some spin off.

      • MeeGhoulz

        Yeah, it took itself seriously and worked pretty good.

        • Necro

          Yeah it did. It was particularly brutal and violent. It’s in my collection.

      • Joe Smith

        No it is considered a remake. It’s the best one after the original too.

        • Necro

          Yeah I really liked it myself

    • Justin Anthony

      One absolutely badass and the other is a complete bore-fest.

      • MeeGhoulz


  • Lord Shockedelic

    Something important to consider is that Silent Night Deadly Night was a wide Holiday release and A Nightmare On Elm Street was regional. Some parts of the country didn’t see ANOES until the following spring. You have to do research beyond the numbers.

    • John Squires

      This was noted in the article: “Granted, it’s not fair to compare given one was released into half as many theaters as the other, but it’s interesting to note that SNDN did out-gross Elm Street in their shared opening weekend.”

  • Necro

    Well you learn something new everyday. 3 Horror franchises were born on November 9th: ‘A Nightmare On Elm Street’, ‘Silent Night, Deadly Night’, & ‘Child’s Play’! Now of course ‘Child’s Play’ didn’t come along until 1988, but still there’s some cool Horror stuff there.

  • Tan Shearer

    I’d say Jason is the most iconic slasher villain of all time not Freddy.

  • What are the indicators of global recognition of persons in this modern world? Not surprisingly, numbers of followers to the Twitter account is truly a firm indication in today. So it’s useful to buy twitter followers as a technique to become well-known.

More in Movies