›

2018 B-D Horror Draft Round 1: Wonderlust vs Mr. Cotton

H.P. PufncraftH.P. Pufncraft
in Forum Games
Wonderlust
1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos
2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore
3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier
4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin
5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani
6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury
7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow
8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley
9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun
10. Terrifier{2018}~
Damien Leone

vs

Mr. Cotton
1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison
2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni
3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert
4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins
5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson
6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982)
7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller
8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman
9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine
10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman

Comments

  • TexasSnacksTexasSnacks is Certified Rotten
    Winner-WL

    WL-11

    Cotton-10
  • BlackDragonShogunBlackDragonShogun Atlanta
    Wonderlust
    1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos +3
    2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore HS
    3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier +2
    4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin HS
    5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani +2
    6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury +2
    7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow +2
    8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley HS
    9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun +3
    10. Terrifier{2018}~
    Damien Leone +2

    vs

    Mr. Cotton
    1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison +3
    2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni +3
    3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert +3
    4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins +3
    5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson HS
    6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982) +3
    7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller +3
    8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman +3
    9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine +2
    10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman HS

    Wonderlust = 16
    Mr. Cotton = 23

    Mr. Cotton wins!
  • Orville KetchumOrville Ketchum
    Wonderlust
    1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos
    2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore
    3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier 3
    4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin
    5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani
    6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury 3
    7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow
    8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley
    9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun
    10. Terrifier{2018}~
    Damien Leone 2

    8

    Mr. Cotton
    1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison 2
    2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni 3
    3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert
    4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins 3
    5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson
    6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982) 2
    7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller 3
    8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman 2
    9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine 3
    10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman 2

    20

    Cotton gmv
  • Freddy_LivesFreddy_Lives in KC
    Wonderlust - 16

    Mr. Cotton - 20

    Cotton wins the vote.
  • nancenance maryland
    Wonderlust
    1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos
    2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore
    3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier
    4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin
    5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani 3
    6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury 4
    7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow 3
    8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley
    9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun 3
    10. Terrifier{2018}~Damien Leone 2

    15

    vs

    Mr. Cotton
    1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison 3
    2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni
    3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert 3
    4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins
    5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson
    6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982)
    7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller 3
    8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman
    9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine 3
    10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman 3

    Tie Breaker:

    winner: wonderlust, 4 coin flips to 3
  • CerraphimCerraphim Syracuse, NY
    edited October 2018
    In the interest of fairness and because I absolutely could not watch everything on everyone's list I picked one from each. I had already seen half from one particular list but most every other film was new to me. I'm still cutting my teeth on horror movies/shows.

    Wonderlust. I watched Lodgers and thoroughly enjoyed it. I think period piece horror films are an area I want to investigate further now. +3!

    Mr. Cotton. The only thing I could get my hands on in your list was Tourist Trap. Thank Puff for lending me a DVD. It was such an odd mixture of creepy and funny but I found myself really into it. +3!

    EDIT: Cerraphim is celebrating her birthday right now and told me to post who she chose as the winner. Wonderlust is the winner.
  • gwallygwally Snowhio
    Wonderlust – 2.33
    1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos
    2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore -- 2
    3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier -- 3
    4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin
    5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani -- 3
    6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury
    7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow -- 1
    8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley -- 3
    9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun
    10. Terrifier{2018}~Damien Leone -- 2

    vs.

    Mr. Cotton – 1.66
    1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison -- 1
    2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni -- 2
    3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert -- 3
    4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins -- 1
    5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson --
    6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982)
    7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller -- 2
    8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman
    9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine -- 1
    10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman --


    Wonderlust
  • H.P. PufncraftH.P. Pufncraft
    Wonderlust
    1. Mandy{2018}~Panos Cosmatos +3
    2. Who's Watching Oliver{2018}~Richie Moore
    3. Incident in a Ghostland{2018}~Pascal Laugier +3
    4. Boarding School{2018}~Boaz Yakin
    5. Tilt{2017}~Kasra Farahani +3
    6. Leatherface{2017}~ Alexandre Bustillo, Julien Maury +2
    7. House of Salem{2016}~James Crow +2
    8. The Lodgers{2018}~Brian O'Malley +3
    9. Boar{2018}~Chris Sun +3
    10. Terrifier{2018}~
    Damien Leone +3

    Total = 22

    vs

    Mr. Cotton
    1. Don't Go in the House (1979) - Joseph Ellison +3
    2. The Night of the Devils (1972) - Giorgio Ferroni +3
    3. Blood and Lace (1971) - Philip S. Gilbert
    4. The Last House on Dead End Street (1977) - Roger Watkins
    5. Superstition (1982) - James W. Roberson +2
    6. Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker A.K.A. Night Warning (1982) +3
    7. Tourist Trap (1979) - David Schmoeller +3
    8. The Pit (1981) - Lew Lehman +3
    9. Neon Maniacs (1986) - Joseph Mangine +3
    10. Just Before Dawn (1981) - Jeff Lieberman +3

    Total = 23

    Mr. Cotton wins
  • H.P. PufncraftH.P. Pufncraft
    edited October 2018
    Wonderlust and Mr. Cotton are tied and will both advance to Round 2.
This discussion has been closed.