Quantcast
/db
Sponsored

Ranking Every Ghost Face Killer in the ‘Scream’ Franchise

If there’s one thing that slashers have established over the years, it’s that these relentless villains always come back. However, not every masked killer boasts the cockroach-like resilience of Jason Voorhees, so filmmakers often take alternate paths to explain why the same antagonist can return in a sequel after being killed in a previous installment.

If you ask me, the best explanation for this tradition happens to be the one cooked up by Wes Craven and Kevin Williamson in the Scream franchise. In those films, Ghost Face is more of a mantle than a true character, with disgruntled killers donning the iconic costume as a way of adding to the mythology of the original Woodsboro murders. That’s why the franchise has seen nearly twenty characters wear the infamous Fun World mask since 1996!

With the franchise showing no sign of stopping even after three decades of meta scares, and NECA‘s Ultimate Ghost Face action figure, fully articulated and equipped with a horrifying haul of accessories, I’ve decided to come up with a list ranking every incarnation of Ghost Face that we’ve seen so far.

Naturally, this ranking is purely based on personal opinion, though I think it’s worth mentioning that I’ll be evaluating killers according to their skill, motivation, and charisma/scare-factor – not the overall quality of the movie they appeared in. I’ll also be bundling groups/pairs of killers together in order to keep things simple.

That being said, don’t forget to comment below with your own personal Ghost Face rankings if you have a different take.

With that out of the way, onto the list!


9. Jessica & Marco – Scream VII (2025)

The seventh entry of the Friday the 13th franchise already had Jason Voorhees facing off against a super-powered Carrie knock-off in an attempt to keep things fresh, so you can imagine that the creative team behind Scream VII had their work cut out for them when they had to come up with yet another original whodunnit without resorting to supernatural shenanigans.

Unfortunately, after so many variations of spurned lovers and vengeful film nerds, having the new pair of killers simply be a middle-aged couple motivated by Sidney’s absence in the previous Ghost Face murders just wasn’t going to cut it. And while I’ll concede that Jessica and Marco had a few brutal kills, that’s not enough to keep them from being the least interesting murderers in the series – especially after all that teasing about Stu Macher possibly still being alive.


8. Jamal & Beth – Scream: Resurrection (2018)

As a fan of the first two seasons of MTV’s Scream, it took me a while to accept Scream Resurrection as a worthy follow-up, even though I’m still sour about the previous show’s lack of a proper conclusion. While Resurrection certainly has its moments, the final reveal behind this urban whodunnit felt pretty underwhelming.

Jamal’s telenovela-like character arc involving twins swapping lives was silly enough, but having his partner’s motives turn out to be pretty much the same as Charlie’s from Scream 4 only compounded the disappointment even if their actual kills weren’t half-bad.


7. Piper & Kieran (+ Tom) – MTV’s Scream (2015-2016)

MTV’s Scream had a lot riding against it when it first came out, with the show not being allowed to use the iconic Fun World mask and presenting itself as more of a teen drama with slasher elements than a proper horror show. However, I’d argue that the showrunners were still able to tell a compelling story within those limitations, with their choice of Ghost Face killers suggesting that they understood what fans loved about the movies.

For instance, the scheming Piper felt like an effective combination of Gail’s darker side with a tinge of inherited fury like we saw in Sam Carpenter later on in the franchise, and I always thought Kieran made for a compelling follow-up to the Billy Loomis bad boy archetype. Hell, even Tom Martin made for an interesting killer despite being the most obvious suspect in the Halloween special, though a lot of that is due to Alexander Calvert’s natural charisma.


6. Richie & Amber – Scream (2022)

Dealing with toxic fandom may be rough, but it’s certainly not as big of a deal as Scream’s ultimate killer reveal makes it out to be – especially since the rest of this requel is more about criticizing the diminishing returns of Legacy Sequels rather than exploring the consequences of having a rabid fanbase.

Thankfully, memorable performances by both Jack Quaid and Mikey Madison more than make up for their characters’ flimsy motivations, with this killer couple being a big part of what made the movie such a big hit. That being said, I’m still a little mad that this is the duo who took out my favorite character in the franchise.


5. Ethan, Quinn & Wayne (+ Jason Carvey) – Scream VI (2023)

I wasn’t a fan of having a killer be motivated by the death of a previous Ghost Face even when Scream 2 did it back in ’97, but I’d argue that the triple threat of Ethan, Quinn and Wayne makes up for the recycled premise by being the most brutal ensemble of killers in the entire franchise.

From shotgun blasts at point-blank range to Anika’s prolonged suffering before falling to her death, Scream VI’s Ghost Face is likely the scariest version of the “character” so far. It’s just too bad that the masked figure loses much of that mystique once the killers’ identities are finally revealed.

I’d also like to give a shout out to that Jason Carvey cameo towards the beginning of the film, as his fake-out killer reveal feels like something straight out of a Stab film.


4. Nancy Loomis & Mickey Altieri – Scream 2 (1997)

While I get the irony of having the sequel’s vengeful killer serve as an inverted callback to Friday the 13th’s Pamela Voorhees, Nancy and her psychotic protégé, wonderfully played by Timothy Olyphant, didn’t quite live up to the over-the-top perfection that was Billy and Stu.

However, that doesn’t mean that Mrs. Loomis and Mickey were any less threatening while wearing the iconic Ghost Face costume, with Scream 2 serving up some of the most thrilling chase sequences in the entire franchise – not to mention a gloriously meta opening kill.


3. Roman Bridger – Scream 3 (2000)

The identity of Scream 3’s solo killer may not make a lot of sense if you pay close attention to the film’s timelin, and pulling a criminal mastermind half-brother out of thin air was a sign that the franchise desperately needed a time-out, but I’m still of the opinion that having the final Ghost Face of the original trilogy be a movie director was a deliciously meta idea.

Not only that, but Roman Bridger was Ghost Face at his most playful, especially with that silly new voice-changer, with the villain tackling Hollywood corruption in what felt like a natural conclusion to a satirical trilogy about the dark side of genre media.

I also love that this is technically the only Ghost Face to have ever performed alongside Creed!


2. Jill & Charlie – Scream 4 (2011)

Hearing a packed theater collectively gasp as Emma Roberts violently injured herself in order to convince the cops that she was a Final Girl remains one of my all-time favorite moviegoing memories. It was also one hell of a way to establish that the mastermind behind this particular murder spree was even more unhinged than her predecessors.

However, it’s not the surprise behind the reveal that Sidney’s own cousin and her cinephile friend Charlie were behind the killings that makes this incarnation of Ghost Face so memorable, nor the creativity behind the death scenes themselves, but the fact that Craven and Williamson so accurately predicted the rise of clout-chasing influencers willing to do anything for fifteen minutes of online fame.

Not only that, but you can also interpret Jill’s plan to force Sidney to “pass the torch” to a new generation as something of a condemnation of Legacy Sequels before they became such a popular way of reviving older horror IPs!


1. Stu Macher & Billy Loomis – Scream (1996)

I don’t think anyone will be surprised with my number one pick, as it’s hard to overstate just how shocking it was back in the day when the original Scream revealed that its movie-obsessed killer was in fact a pair of deeply disturbed high-schoolers!

This unique choice of murderers fit perfectly within the film’s meta exploration of a culture that might be a little too obsessed with media, but Skeet Ulrich and Mathew Lillard’s oddly sexy rapport was also so iconic that the franchise is still struggling to recreate that once-in-a-generation movie magic three decades down the line!

That’s why no one else could have taken the number one spot!


You can bring the Ultimate Ghost Face home for Halloween.