Connect with us


[‘Aliens’ Revisited] The Perfect Sequel, Just As Good As Its Predecessor In Completely Different Ways

With the June 8th release of Ridley Scott’s Prometheus fast approaching, we thought we’d take a look back at the original Alien franchise with which it “shares strands of DNA.” Whether or not there are xenomorphs as we know them in Prometheus, it’s abundantly clear that it takes place in the same universe.

In the weeks leading up to the release of that film I’m going to revisit the four films in the Alien franchise (sorry, not going to subject myself to AVP) in order to gather my thoughts in anticipation of the new outing. Last week I revisited Alien: Resurrection and absolutely hated it. The week before that I revisited Alien 3 and discovered a lot to like.

Now we come down to the two titans in the series, and this week I’m taking another look at Aliens. This is one of my favorite movies and I bet it’s one of yours as well. But what makes it tick? And is it better than Alien?

Let’s talk more inside.

The headline of this article is something of a fallacy. I don’t need to ‘revisit’ Aliens. I mean, sure I watched it again recently before writing this piece – but it’s such a regulation piece of viewing for me that I know it by the back of my hand. Both cuts. Saying I frequently ‘revisit’ Aliens would be like saying I frequently ‘revisit’ oxygen and food. That being said…

During the lead up to Prometheus it’s been impossible to avoid the discussion of which film is better, Aliens or Alien. What’s my answer? Both. I’ll get more into this next week during my revisit of the original Alien – but I truly feel that both are equal in incredibly different ways. I love the Anamorphic 2.35:1 Widescreen of the 1979 original, it’s without a doubt the best looking film in the entire franchise (and it’s over 30 years old). Contrasted with the grainy 1.85:1 of Aliens there’s absolutely no contest between the aesthetics of the two films (one is a great looking action movie and the other is a flat-out gorgeous film – no qualifiers needed). Alien is a perfect horror movie with sci-fi elements – it combines slashers, body-horror and existential dread all into one adding great characters and an ingenious creature design along the way. Meanwhile, Aliens is a perfect action film with horror/sci-fi elements. Both films land the objectives of their intent perfectly.

So what’s one thing Aliens has over Alien? Well, between the two – it’s the first one you reach for on your video shelf. Have a friend over that’s never seen one of these movies? Technically, some might say you should show them Alien to preserve the suspense of who makes it off the Nostromo blah… blah… blah… Except they already know Sigourney Weaver as the face of the franchise, so what’s the point? There was a seven year window when people could approach the first film without knowing the answer to that, and it ended in 1986. No, if you have a friend over who has never seen one of these movies you show them Aliens because it’s the most fun and the most immediately satisfying. And watching it out of order does no disservice to the original because after seeing the sequel, people will be dying to see the first and will be more likely to give themselves over to it completely.

One misconception about Aliens is that it’s not suspenseful. I don’t know where the propagators of this lie come from, but they’re absolutely insane. Have they not heard the line “they’re inside the room?” The use of the motion detector in both movies is incredibly suspenseful but I’d argue that Aliens ratchets up its efficacy a notch. Also suspenseful? The entire 3rd act of the film.

Act 3 of Aliens escalates beat by beat in a way that most modern action films could only hope to match. The reactor melting down the whole time, the xenomorphs staging a siege on the marines, Bishop trying to remote pilot the drop ship, Newt getting separated from Ripley and Hicks and being taken to the Queen’s hive – all perfect. But the film doesn’t stop there. If you want to know the difference between Aliens and most of today’s modern blockbusters – it can be found in the moment where Ripley hones in on the signal from Newt’s tracking bracelet, follows it and finally arrives to find that it’s been torn off. Most action films would have ceased their escalatory ascent before this point, content to devolve in a series of whirring gears and explosions. With Aliens, James Cameron was smart enough to know that the best action sequences are centered around achieving a recognizable objective and dangling that objective in and out of the protagonist’s reach. Ripley finding the abandoned bracelet is one of my favorite action beats in cinema because it’s not the first in its sequence nor is it the last (not by a long shot) – it’s just a perfect note in the film’s symphony.

Aliens is also interesting in that it shifts genre away from the original film. It’s still very much set in the same universe and feels like an organic continuation of Ripley’s story – but it is an action film. This might be where some people err in claiming that it’s not suspenseful. Whereas Alien was quietly suspenseful, Aliens is ear shatteringly loud in places. It’s also epilepsy inducing in moments, with all of the strobing gunfire. It’s not as concerned with slow burn reveals of biology as it is in dropping its characters into the most untenable situation possible.

And what great characters they are. While Michael Biehn’s Hicks is stoically flat by design, the rest of them pop off the screen. Bill Paxton’s Hudson is one of cinema’s all time great cowardly lions. Watching William Hope’s Gorman devolve/evolve from an above-it-all and by-the-book leader into one of the rest of them is simultaneously touching and a nice bit of schadenfreude. Lance Henriksen brings an almost wounded quality to Bishop while making him a convincing synthetic – you almost want to hug him and tell him how sorry you are he’s not human. Jeanette Goldstein’s Vasquez could be seen as a slight misstep in the James Cameron mold of occasionally writing women as men, but she seemed pretty revolutionary at the time.

Speaking of characters, while Hudson may be the most quotable, Paul Reiser’s Carter Burke is probably the best of the bunch. You know he’s a rat bastard right from the start, but you can understand why the other characters don’t realize how evil and sleazy he is until it’s too late. Burke is highly charismatic and totally evil and you want to see him die. But he’s also a great externalization of this franchise’s deep-seated mistrust of corporations. You knew that there were some nefarious elements to the Weyland-Yutani corporation in the first film. After all, everything and everyone aboard the Nostromo was expendable in favor of safe transport of the xenomorph back to Earth. Reiser’s character puts a face to that evil and reminds us of the banal, human component to almost every massively inhumane decision ever made. The component that shrugs its shoulders, says “it had to be done” and goes home to its wife and kids.

The film’s “motherhood” theme is oft-discussed. A lot of people find it too on the nose but I think it’s pitched pretty much perfectly. In a film this busy, loud and chaotic – sometimes the text needs to be a little more pronounced. For this reason, I actually (slightly) prefer the director’s cut. While I can do without the early scenes on LV-426 (the stuff with Newt’s family prior to the colony’s destruction weakens the cut somewhat – I like arriving at the colony and knowing it only as a ghost town), the information that Ripley has lost her daughter is fairly crucial and is not represented in the theatrical cut of the film. It’s the third leg of the thematic tripod, the other two being Newt herself and the Alien Queen’s dismay and anger (and vengeance) over seeing her eggs burned before her very eyes. It also goes the extra mile toward selling us on Ripley’s descent back into the bowels of hell to get Newt. It’s an action easily explained by standard movie heroism, but knowing what Ripley has lost before and being aware of her emotional need to do everything she can to achieve an approximation of correction for that loss adds the extra bit of pathos that makes it tick more completely.

We’ll talk more about Alien next week, but I really do think Aliens is its equal (again, based on a different set of merits). Violent, scary, human, funny, ambitious, captivating – action films aren’t made like Aliens anymore. I know this is probably the most cliche’d thing I could say at this point, but I seriously defy you to find me an example of something from the last 10 years that even comes close.



  • CountOrlok

    Aliens is a good movie but definitely overrated. The buildup and atmosphere is superb until the end where Ripley suddenly turns into Rambo and you get that cheesy monster fight at the end. It ruins the movie for me.

    • MrDisgusting

      It’s incredible. The end.

    • I agree with you CountOrlok, it’s definitely overrated and is not the movie I first reach for in the Alien series, the original one is.

    • felixbrewer

      Made an account to respond to this but I will keep it civil. I am very new here and I’ve just been lurking a bit but I couldn’t let this go.

      Alien is second only to ALIENS as my favorite movie of all time but I recognize that some of my lean toward the latter is emotional and personal. When I have attempted to be more objective about them as films, I can still only lower ALIENS to being an equal in a different genre as this article has stated.
      I respect that you don’t enjoy the ‘Rambo’ Ripley(but I do disagree with that description) or the ‘cheesy monster fight'(I also disagree with that and don’t even get me started on your flat out disrespect of what Stan Winston and co. achieved with that scene) at the end, but please don’t call an obvious masterpiece of action, horror, and sci-fi cinema ‘overrated’. You sound like an… well let’s say you sound like a pretentious jerk.

      It’s your opinion and you are entitled to it of course but your wording is what I take issue with.

  • WalkingDeadGuy

    It is indeed incredible. Other than the shot of adrenaline administered by Mr. James Cameron, the reason I love it more over Alien is due to how well we get to know the characters. Specifically in the “directors cut’ version of the film, you really get to understand Ripley’s rapport with Newt and why she’s willing to do anything for her. It is truly a perfect film.

  • Nothing333

    Aliens. Better than the original IMO (the orig is great too). Top ten of all time for sure. This movie can never be overrated. Sorry.

  • Rusted

    This movie is just and one of the best sequels ever. The directors cut is the way to go. It has a meaty story, completely fleshed out and distinct characters, it is suspenseful, the action is flat out amazing, plenty of horror and it’s Sigourneys best performance. Cameron directed the shit outta this one. Just brilliant.

  • turtlenipple

    Sharp sticks. I fuckin love Aliens, the original takes second place for me.

  • The Dark Knight imo does all of these things also.
    There’s your 1 movie

    • Jasonicus

      Uh, no.

    • EvanDickson

      Apples and Oranges. But the Dark Knight doesn’t have nearly the sense of escalation that Aliens does.

  • saft-und-kraft

    I actually think the special edition is hurt by the additional footage at the beginning. it’s actually kinda painful to watch and obvious why he cut it out of the theatrical run. plus id diffuses the theatrical version build up to the creatures an hour into it. now having said that (and that is from an adult standpoint not a childs perspective which is when I first saw the theatrical version on video in 87 i think) I always watch the extended cut every time. why you ask? because I am greedy and I always want more and more from my films. do I want an 8 hour Thin Red Line? yes! do I want all of Kevin Smith’s films to include all the deleted footage? yes! so I always watch my Aliend, Aliens, and Alien 3 extended/special/director cuts. peace.

  • Totally agree

  • LAPD

    When I was in the military we’d sit around in the barracks when we were bored and we’d throw Aliens in, grab a few cold beers, and start quoting Hudson word for word. We’d then spend the next few days at work calling each Hudson. Definitely a classic and I’d put it above Alien, which I dig too.

  • isoph0451

    The original will always be my favorite, I love the strangling atmosphere, the style, the suspense and the overall mystery of it. But, that being said, the sequel is an awesome movie, and definitely one of the best sequels in cinema history (next to Godfather Pt. II). Cameron was really smart to try and explore different territory than just trying to copy the original.

  • warment

    Aliens is my favorite movie of all time. Just ordered the Alien Quadrilogy for the extended cuts of the first 3 movies. Never saw the extended cuts of Alien or Alien3. Loved the extended bits in Aliens…especially the servo guns…

  • djblack1313

    Excuse me, “did IQ’s drop sharply while i was away!” (i love that line from ALIENS as well as “they mostly come at night….mostly”. lol.) i really love both movies but if i HAD to pick one as my fave it would be ALIENS (probably in part because i was too young to see the first movie in theaters and Cameron’s movie came out at a time when i was old enough to appreciate it). Vasquez was awesome as was Hicks, Hudson, etc! i DO like Newt and her family’s part (with the Space Jockey’s ship etc) but i can see why some people think it detracts from the flow of the movie. i have a strong feeling that PROMETHEUS is going to be my favorite from this Ridley Scott setting.

  • lucie-with-a-gun

    i saw alien first. after seeing it i had no idea what the alien was. that made it scariest. aliens turns them into bug and over exposes them so there is no more frightening mystery. subsequent alien sequels maintain that same identity for the xenomorph and all of the sequels lack that first films sense of body horror and fear of what isnt known about the alien.

  • I agree with everything in this article. And it is the one I would show randomly to a friend because, as much as I love the first one, I feel like people today aren’t patient enough to sit through the slow build of the original. But if they see Aliens first, they’re already invested and won’t notice the slow build as much.

  • badass flick. best sequel ever. woulda loved to watch a marines spin off flick/tv show.

  • Evan3

    Completely agree Evan, asking which is “better” is futile, they both are classic, great films, with separate merits. Cameron pulled off a stunning feat in making a original sequel still intertwined by the universe created by another director. I doubt Cameron could (or more accurately, would want to) pull off such a feat today.

  • Mako

    While I love both ALIEN and ALIENS… I hold ALIENS slightly above the original… which sounds insane. Why? As much as ALIEN is incredible for being the first… ALIENS to be has more layers. Not only does Cameron add in the dimension of a “mother-children” theme which organically leads into the introduction of the Queen… but what Evan didn’t mention above… is that Cameron also played into a future “vietnam” scenario. Where it didn’t matter that the humans had the best kick ass weapons money could buy… they still got their asses kicked. I still consider both to be classics. And ALIENS to be one of the few sequels to be as good if not better than the original. That rarely happens.


    Aliens is a masterpiece better than the original? Yes while the original had sum seriously immense scenes the motion tracking in the vents or the chest busting scene i feel that it does not compete with the absolute epicness of the marines first encoutering the aliens u can quote the entire movie the characters are so likeable when vasquez shouts ”LETS ROCK” who did not scream at the tv FUCK YEAH i re-watched it last night and really did love the gorman character when they went through the vents and he had truly became a marine shouting orders never leaving a soldier behind all that so great. All the marines were superb i truly hate that Drake had to go so early he was a fucking badass but it also added to the sense that these things were no joke plus u got see an alien get a shotgun shoved in its mouth ”eat this” incredible.Aliens is the greatest sequel of all time and easily makes my top 10 movies ever.Game over

  • Less Lee Moore

    Just found this today and it’s fantastic. Thanks for writing it.

More in Editorials