Today is one of those pleasing times where numbers line up on the calendar perfectly. Today is the 22nd day of the 2 month of the year 2022, and also a Tuesday. So yes, it’s TwosDay, and how else could I mark this occasion than with a listicle of some of the best horror game sequels ever made. Now we’re not talking third, fourth, or eighth entries into a series here, just the first direct sequels to classic horror games. The ones that pushed the original aside by being generally better.

There’s obviously debatable ones out there that I’ve chosen not to include. Is The Last of Us Part II superior to the first? Did Dead Space 2 outstrip its predecessor? Is Bioshock 2 actually the only good one? Am I totally wrong about Devil May Cry 2 being a urine-stained rag of a sequel? There were still plenty of other sequels with strong cases, so here’s seven of the best horror game sequels in my eyes.

Clock Tower 2 (1996, PlayStation)

While it was known as plain old Clock Tower outside Japan, the 1996 entry in the franchise is actually the second game, and quite the visual leap from its predecessor as one of PlayStation’s early 3D horror titles.

This point n’ click adventure takes the scares to Scandanavia, but brings back iconic villain Scissorman to torment original protagonist Jennifer Simpson all over again.

How it Improves on the Original

The original game was on the Super Famicom, and the sequel utilized the extra oomph of the original PlayStation to powerful effect. The three-dimensional perspective and camera angles accentuate the unnerving dread of the first game, and the deliberately off-kilter soundtrack only adds to it.

Also of note is the choice. Players can be either Jennifer or the new character Helen, and depending on which is chosen and what decisions they make in the first half of the game, it will impact the second half where it switches to the other.

Resident Evil 2 (1998, Multi)

After the incredible success of Resident Evil in 1996, there was unsurprisingly much anticipation for more. In came Resident Evil 2, an expansive continuation of the original story with bigger stakes and bigger threats to match. 

Rookie cop Leon Kennedy and Chris Redfield’s sister Claire end up in Raccoon City on the day of a citywide zombie outbreak. Along the way are tragedy, terror, conspiracy, and lots of shuffling undead.

How it Improves on the Original

Simply put, it just feels so much bigger. There’s undoubtedly a charm to the Spencer Mansion and its secrets, but getting to traverse a city on the brink of collapse was something else. If the original was lifting the lid on Umbrella’s dark secrets, Resident Evil 2 kicks the lid clean off.

The dual campaigns hold their own significant story beats. Leon tangles with seductive spy Ada Wong, while Claire finds herself protecting a child in distress in Sherry Burton. The best part though? The sheer variety of monsters. From that classic Licker introduction on, Resident Evil 2 drip-feeds gnarly nasties including a giant alligator, big hairy spiders, a constantly mutating monster, and of course, the hulking trenchcoat fan Mr.X. Truly deserving to be mentioned as one of the best horror game sequels.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 (2014, Multi)

Five Nights at Freddy’s relative simplicity and release that coincided with the YouTubers getting scared on camera boom saw it become an instant hit. Players are trapped in a small room with power to doors and vents slowly draining. All the while, animatronic creatures close in on you with murderous intent. Fail and you get a jumpscare, succeed, and you live to fight another night. This simple premise became something far deeper as sequels arrived though.

How it Improves on the Original

With FNAF already being quite barebones to begin with, a sequel didn’t have to do a lot to be ‘improved’ and some would question FNAF2’s much steeper difficulty curve as an improvement. It did make most encounters more intense though, and minigames offered up backstory behind the dark past of Freddy Fazbear and his robotic chums. 

There’s also different strategies for the animatronics to keep you on your toes including a mask that fools certain foes, and a flashlight to prevent some unpleasant close encounters. While other games here go further to stake a claim as one of the best horror game sequels, FNAF2 arguably propelled the series into the stratosphere even with relatively minor tweaks.

The Evil Within 2 (2017, Multi)

There was genuine excitement for The Evil Within. Resident Evil and Devil May Cry creator Shinji Mikami was back in the horror realm with what looked like the antidote to the increasingly ridiculous Resi series and the decaying quality of Silent Hill. It didn’t quite work, and that impacted the sequel’s impact somewhat. Despite this, The Evil Within 2 is a truly superior sequel.

Taking place in a digital mind space that is being plagued by a killer and a host of disturbing monstrous threats, Sebastian Castellanos returns to enter this virtual hell in search of his daughter.

How it Improves on the Original

The original was obsessed with being a grimy, gore porn-laden lesson in brutality, which was a bit too blunt for my tastes. The Evil Within 2 goes for eccentricity and violent style. There’s notes of Argento, De Palma, Lynch to the mind-bending madness, and more than a little of Satoshi Kon’s Paprika flavoring the concept as well. 

This more open play space being the fragments of a mind in revolt means the rules of logic and science can be, and are, flipped on their head. Not only does it end up being a far more enthralling game than its predecessor, it feels much more like a spiritual successor to the weird and wonderful beginnings of the survival horror genre.

Left 4 Dead 2 (2009, Xbox 360, PC)

When Valve made video games on a fairly consistent basis, it was relatively untouchable. Half-Life, Portal, and Left 4 Dead all emerged as important markers in video gaming’s history. Left 4 Dead took the flagging zombie apocalypse formula and didn’t just breath new life into it, it put the defibrillators to it. 

A cooperative zombie-slaying experience like no other, Left 4 Dead built systems upon the classic conundrums of the zombie apocalypse and proved there was much more to be mined from them. Just like Half-Life and Portal, it got a sequel that arguably topped it. Valve makes great sequels so Left 4 Dead 2 was an obvious choice for one of the best horror game sequels ever made.

How it Improves on the Original

The A.I. Director was the core of what made Left 4 Dead special. It pushed and pulled at players to better suit their style and ability. In Left 4 Dead 2, it gets a juicy upgrade that not only encourages teamwork more, but throws devilish changes into each map to shake each playthrough up. No point in memorizing a stage when it can throw up fresh surprises at a moment’s notice every time you play.

The new location also peps things up. The journey through North America’s South throws up twisted encounters (an unusual wedding ceremony comes to mind) and the intriguing threat of treacherous weather alongside the usual host of weird and wonderful monsters.

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly (2003, PS2, Xbox)

Snapping away at terrifying images is something I’m keen to avoid, hence why I don’t do Instagram, but if anything captures the true perils of photography it’s the Fatal Frame series. In the original title, a supernatural device known as the Camera Obscura can repel and vanquish spirits if lined up correctly in its viewfinder. Of course, that leaves the player in a vulnerable, static state.

The sequel, Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly, took confident strides from its predecessor, both narratively and in terms of its atmosphere of melancholic dread. I’d say it’s another easy contender for the best horror game sequels in most people’s eyes.

How it Improves on the Original

A more compelling story was definitely the key reason Crimson Butterfly is held in higher regard. Twin sisters return to a place from their childhood, and end up stumbling into a village full of tormented spirits. What’s their connection to this place? What does the crimson butterfly of the title signify? Fatal Frame II gives plenty of reasons to endure its scares. It’s a damn sight scarier this time too. The game allows for greater damage to spirits if you let them get closer, and that ramps up the intensity and anxiety of encounters greatly.

Silent Hill 2 (2001, PS2, Xbox, PC)

The original Silent Hill offered up an interesting alternative to Capcom’s Resident Evil series. A more psychological, atmospheric take on horror, with an intimidating (and necessary) fog shrouding the titular town as protagonist Harry Mason descends into his own personal hell. So began a rivalry that would sadly end quite prematurely for Konami’s franchise. Still, has Resident Evil ever managed to produce something as remarkable as Silent Hill 2?

How it Improves on the Original

It’s easy to understate just how much of a leap Silent Hill 2 is from its predecessor. Silent Hill is good, even if time hasn’t been kind to it, but Silent Hill 2 is frankly a masterpiece. It remains one of gaming’s best stories, channeling David Lynch in a strong way, but very much its own beast. James Sunderland’s search for his wife in Silent Hill goes from surreal to absurd, to terrifying, and all the way back around with masterful grace. Then there’s Pyramid Head. Easily one of the most iconic monsters in all of gaming.

Not only could you argue Silent Hill 2 is the best of the best horror game sequels, it’s one of the finest games ever made.