Fox Hollow Farm (Westfield, IN)
Herb Baumeister unfortunately committed suicide before he was caught, thus he never confessed to the murders. In the early 1990s, he would pick up young gay men at bars and bring them home to his 18-acre farm, where he lived with his wife. It was she who finally allowed the police to search the house, where they found the remains of 11 men, 8 of whom were identified. Rob and Vicki Graves eventually purchased the property, and even went so far as to claim that they would see the ghosts of Baumeister’s victims. Why they would choose to stay there after that is beyond me.
Find out if the Collins’ house becomes the horror genre’s next murder house when Sinister 2 opens in theaters everywhere this Friday August 21st!
